CivilCase
Sign inGet started
CivilCase/Small Claims/Online Seller Disputes

How to sue an online seller in small claims court.

Amazon, eBay, Etsy, Facebook Marketplace, Venmo/Cash App scams, gig services, FedEx. Each has its own recovery path. Most platform disputes get solved through their own buyer-protection programs — so try those first. For peer-to-peer payment scams and Marketplace fraud, small claims under your state's consumer-protection laws is usually the move.

$4,500
$6,200
$3,800
$2,800
$5,400
$4,200

What kind of online-seller dispute are you having?

Each platform has different recovery paths. Pick yours for state-specific advice.

All online seller disputes
Pick the one that fits your situation. Each links to a state-specific guide.
Online seller (general)
Try the platform's buyer-protection program first (Amazon A-to-z, eBay Money Back Guarantee, Etsy case system). If that fails, sue under your state's consumer-protection law in small claims.
Amazon seller
Amazon's A-to-z Guarantee covers you for up to $2,500 per claim and usually resolves within 30 days. Small claims is your backup if Amazon denies the claim.
eBay seller
eBay's Money Back Guarantee covers items that never arrived or weren't as described. Small claims is your backup if eBay denies the claim.
Etsy seller
Etsy's case system handles most disputes and tends to favor buyers. Custom orders get some flexibility, but the seller still can't misrepresent the item.
Facebook Marketplace seller
Marketplace has no buyer protection. File a police report if it was outright theft. Small claims under your state's consumer-protection law is the path to your money back.
Venmo / Cash App scam
Peer-to-peer payment apps won't reverse a payment you authorized — even if it turned out to be a scam. Federal law only protects you when your account was hacked. Small claims is your path for the rest.
DoorDash / Uber / Uber Eats
Their terms of service force most disputes into private arbitration — but they almost always carve out small claims. If your dollar amount is within your state's cap, you can sue.
FedEx package
Federal law (the Carmack Amendment) governs interstate shipments. The default coverage is just $100 per package — you can pay more for 'declared value' coverage. Small claims is your path when FedEx denies a claim.
Popular right now:

How small claims handles online-seller disputes.

Online-seller cases have layered options. Platform programs (Amazon A-to-z, eBay MBG, Etsy cases) settle most disputes for free. Credit-card chargebacks cover almost everything else. Small claims is the right court when those fail and the loss is within your state’s cap, especially with state UDAP multipliers.

✓
BELONGS IN SMALL CLAIMS
5
01
Refunds the platform refused.
When Amazon, eBay, or Etsy denied your case but the seller is clearly at fault. Bring the case decision with you.
02
Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist fraud.
No platform protection. Your state's consumer-protection law steps in — many states let you ask for 2x or 3x damages.
03
Peer-to-peer payment scams (Venmo, Zelle, Cash App).
These apps won't reverse a payment you authorized, even if you got scammed. Small claims is the way back.
04
Gig-service damages.
DoorDash, Instacart, Uber Eats, ride-share. Their terms of service force most disputes into arbitration, but small claims is almost always carved out.
05
Lost or damaged shipments.
FedEx, UPS, USPS. Federal law (Carmack Amendment) covers interstate shipments; state law for in-state.
×
DOESN’T BELONG HERE
4
01
Disputes still in platform review.
Wait for the case to close. Filing in small claims while a platform case is open often gets dismissed.
02
Class-action-type claims.
Identical complaints by many buyers usually get rolled into class-action settlements.
03
International seller disputes.
Service of process and judgment enforcement abroad usually make small claims impractical.
04
Damages above the cap.
Big-ticket items (vehicles, electronics over the limit) need higher courts.
DAMAGES

What can you recover?

The math judges use. A typical online-seller case stacks the price you paid, the cost of mitigation (return shipping, replacement at higher price), and any UDAP multiplier your state allows.

Refund of purchase price

What you paid for the item or service that did not arrive or was not as described.

$1,200
Base amount
Consumer-protection penalty

Many state consumer-protection laws add 2x or 3x damages plus attorney fees when the seller engaged in fraud or deceptive practices.

+$1,200
Multiplier
Mitigation costs

Return shipping, replacement at higher price, lost time, restocking fee. Keep the receipts.

+$300
Typical recovery
Filing fee + interest

Filing fee, service-of-process cost, pre-judgment interest at the state legal rate.

+$200
Accruing
ESTIMATED RECOVERY
$2,900
Sample math on a $1,200 misrepresented Amazon order in a 2x-multiplier state. Your numbers will differ.
BUILD THE FILE

What evidence do you need to sue an online seller?

Online-seller cases live in screenshots. The listing, the order confirmation, the messages with the seller, and the platform case decision are the spine of the case. Pull everything before the listing or message thread disappears.

Original listing screenshot

What was promised. Listings change or disappear after disputes; capture it the moment something feels off.

Order confirmation and receipt

Confirmation email, invoice, or platform receipt with order number, date, and amount.

Messages with the seller

Platform messages, emails, texts. Especially anything where the seller acknowledges the problem or refuses to fix it.

Payment record

Bank statement, credit-card line item, or payment-app screenshot showing the dollar amount and date.

Platform case decision

Amazon A-to-z, eBay MBG, Etsy case outcome. If they ruled against you, print the decision; it shows you exhausted the platform.

Photos of what arrived

Side-by-side with the listing photos. Damage, wrong item, counterfeit, or empty box. Include packaging if relevant.

BY STATE

State-specific rules.

UDAP multipliers (2x or 3x in many states), pre-judgment interest, and consumer-protection statutes vary by state. Pick yours for the exact rules.

See all 50 state guides
TAKE THE NEXT STEP

Three ways to move forward.

Amazon, eBay, Etsy, Facebook Marketplace, Venmo/Cash App scams, gig services, FedEx. Each has its own recovery path. Mos…

01
PATH A
RECOMMENDED
Send a Demand Letter
Start with formal pressure. Most cases settle here.
From $29
Start my letter
02
PATH B
Check My Case Strength
Free 90-second read with general information about your dispute. Not legal advice.
Free
Continue
03
PATH C
File Your Claim
Skip ahead. Get county-specific filing forms ready to file.
From $79
Continue
RESULT · TOM K.
$1,400 won

“Amazon seller shipped a counterfeit. A-to-z denied it. Court ordered the $1,400 refund.”

Buyer · Ohio
FAQ

Online Seller Disputes questions.

The questions buyers actually ask before filing.

Can I sue an online seller in small claims court?

Yes. Most platforms have their own buyer-protection programs (Amazon's A-to-z, eBay's Money Back Guarantee, Etsy's case system). Try those first — they're free and resolve in 30-60 days. If the platform denies your case, state consumer-protection laws apply (many states let you ask for 2x or 3x damages). Small claims is right when the dollar amount is within your state's cap.

What's the difference between Amazon and Facebook Marketplace?

Amazon, eBay, and Etsy have buyer-protection programs that resolve disputes within their platform. Facebook Marketplace has no platform protection — you're on your own. For Marketplace, your two paths are: dispute the charge with your credit-card company, or file a small-claims case under your state's consumer-protection law.

Can I sue Venmo or Cash App scams?

Yes, but the peer-to-peer apps themselves won't reverse a payment you authorized. Federal law (Regulation E) only protects you when someone hacked your account. For authorized payments that turned out to be scams, your path is small claims under your state's consumer-protection law. For clear theft, also file a police report.

Can I sue DoorDash or Uber?

Yes, in small claims. Their terms of service force most disputes into private arbitration, but small claims is almost always carved out as an option. Read the relevant section of their terms before filing.

How do I sue FedEx?

Federal law (the Carmack Amendment) governs interstate shipments. The default coverage is only $100 per package — pay for 'declared value' coverage if you ship something more expensive. File a claim with FedEx directly first; small claims is your backup if they deny it.